I really wish Pink Truth would stop ruining things for women who are excited about starting Mary Kay. My new team member was SO excited when she signed her agreement and then her sister sent her a link to this site. Of course after reading here for an hour she suddenly had a million questions about inventory and how much directors make and how many people actually make money.

Why do you have to do that? Does this make you proud of yourself when you ruin someone’s dreams? Why is it up to you to decide if people partcipate???

My team member was excited! She had already made her list of 100 people and we were going to meet to talk about her inventory options. Now she says she wants to “think about it” before ordering anything. She even asked me to show her how much I made last year. That is honestly none of her business. I don’t know why anyone thinks I need to show them a tax return, but I have to be nice about it or she might quit.

I told her there will always be negative people trying to steal your dream. If you go looking for reasons something won’t work, of course you’ll find them. Successful people don’t spend hours researching all the reasons they might fail before they even get started.

She still hasn’t placed her inventory order and I’m pretty sure she’s not going to. So congratulations Pink Truth. You probably think you saved her from something. I think you just talked a woman out of taking a chance on herself.

And now our unit is short of our goal too, so thanks for that.

37 COMMENTS

  1. “Successful people don’t spend hours researching all the reasons they might fail before they even get started.”

    Wanna bet? Its called risk analysis, and successful people do this regularly.

    PTC, your recruit’s questions are entirely reasonable. Your reaction is not.

    38
    1
    • They do indeed. SWOT, PESTLE are just basic elements of that. Anyone starting a small business needs to do both these things. As well as market research. Demographics. Competitors. And can negotiate contracts like exclusive distribution rights, product formulation, manufacturing process, territory protection, etc. Except you can’t with MK. You can’t change the formulation so it doesn’t break up in shipping.

      I have a friend in charge of production and product development at a cosmetic manufacturing plant. He gets to decide formulations and production processes, from formulating the latest lipstick to buying a new RF welder for packaging. They did a cost-benefit analysis and found the higher throughput of an RF heater compared to a standard thermal tube crimper was worth it and started a second production line. I told him about the snail mucin MK have just launched. Loled. “That’s actually a thing? That went out years ago.” And he agrees with me, it’ll be a hot seller in the cruelty free vegan clean market that’s the latest trend. And threw shade on the Dollar Tree packaging. He has the same view as me, MK are cutting costs and the broken blushes and eyeshadows are due to crappy formulation and being yeeted through the kilns at too high a speed and too low a temperature to bake properly. Hence they are as fragile as the typical MLM-slinger’s ego.

      Anyway if you are starting a real small business, analyse everything. Check out the marketplace, your competitors, what’s your USP? What differentiates you from everyone else? Where’s the gap in the market? What’s your innovation? What risks and challenges will you face? How will you overcome them? What’s the Political, Environmental Social Technological Legislative Economic situation? What are your strengths, weaknesses, threats, opportunities? How will you manage this? Negotiate and haggle with your suppliers. Formulate a marketing and business plan – there are great templates online. Watch Dragons Den/Shark Tank.

      13
      • A good place to get started is the old Solaris and IBM templates from OxygenOffice on SourceForge which contain marketing_plan.ott and business_plan.ott as well as various business spreadsheets. They are openable in LibreOffice if you add the extensions and don’t want to install OxygenOffice (I’m using Ubuntu and just extracted the templates from the .ext) and MS Word and Excel. MS Office also contains various business templates too for Word and Excel and has a basic CRM in Access. I’m that old I remember Office 2000 Pro Small Business which contained a huge number of templates from business plans to cash flow analysis. ONLYOFFICE (a free office suite) also contains business templates. A Google search also throws up plenty of documents too.

        For project management if you don’t want to fork out for MS Project or you use Mac or Linux ProjectLibre is a great alternative for project management and has some cloud integration.

        GNUCash is a double book-keeping app which is designed for business. It has the ability to generate tax reports when the IRS come knocking for their annual pound of flesh if you can’t afford Quickbooks or Sage.

        OpenBravo is a cloud-based ERP system that manages POS and inventory but is probably too advanced for a home/SME business. I’d just recommend using a spreadsheet or database to manage inventory and track sales.

        There’s plenty of good business tools out there for the small business owner. And these can be used to track your MLM business too. Tracy also has a basic cash flow expense vs income spreadsheet here too.

        If you aren’t using these tools for your MLM you should. If it’s a business then you should be using these tools to plan your business and ensure you don’t get into doo-doo with the IRS. An MK seller got audited a while ago, the fallout is documented here in all it’s glory. You can’t claim your daughter’s volleyball as a business trip if you are going there anyway and just hand out business cards and lipstick samples. Those tax writeoffs can, will and do bite you hard in the tooshie if you are not careful. And if you don’t make profit in 3 years, manage your business using tools, pivot to make a profit or just shut down if you aren’t seeing profit then the IRS say it’s a hobby and not a business. And your business must pass the straight face test. Yes the IRS have criterion for what they call the straight face test. And the pink bubble crashes down around your ears in tax court. You should be using a CPA too. And not MK Math tax folklore which often borders into sovcit territory.

        • Bonus points for the sovcit reference! Those clowns have a special talent for taking a basic traffic stop that could be resolved with a ticket or a warning and turning it into a felony. The window breaks are so satisfying. (Van Balion channel on YT)

          • Great another cop rabbit hole to dive down. Midwest Safety keeps me through the dark lonely hours of insomnia. I’m lol-ing at Lord Justice Rooke’s takedown of covcitery and footleism in Canada. It’s a bureaucratic legalese diss track. Promissory notes were a valid instrument useful in some circumstances until these clowns got near them and tanked them and now nobody uses them as they are as stigmatized as MLMism is. They are still legally valid documents but are so sullied that nobody dare issue or accept them, even if they lack a gold fringe and bloody thumbprints and other woo-woo doodles.

            • I watch Midwest Safety! Sergeant Curtis is another really good one. He talks about why cops do what they do, explains the case law behind their decisions, and critiques the videos he’s presenting. Good stuff, have learned a lot. He covers plenty of sovcits.

      • These are all great open source suggestions, but you don’t even have to be very knowledgeable and AI can do detailed business plans and market analysis!

        1
        1
        • You would entrust your money to AI? It lies, hallucinates and tells you what you want to hear … just like a recruiter.

          To get good answers out of a computer analysis you need to input good data, and you can’t get the data you need from Mary Kay … like how many IBCs are in your area.

          7
          1
          • I share your reservations about AI, but have done this recently to investigate a business idea I had. You need to construct your prompt so that the AI produces an artifact that is detailed and has source references. Tell it exactly what questions to investigate and what methodology to use.
            Sadly, in the world that is already here, AI fluency is a must. I still always read and throughly test any code it writes (even when there are unit tests). The technology has also come a mind-bogglingly long way in the past 12-18 months in terms of hallucination.
            What a time to be alive – just this week I’ve been shamed both for using AI and not for using it enough!

  2. “I would have been an NSD by now, if it weren’t for you meddling kids!”

    “Successful people don’t spend hours researching all the reasons they might fail before they even get started.” Yes, they do, and that’s why they succeed. Armed with facts about income potential, expenses, market demand and competition they decide whether it will be profitable for them or not. If it’s too risky, they decline.

    “after reading here for an hour she suddenly had a million questions about inventory and how much directors make and how many people actually make money.” So … she asked for the facts you didn’t tell her as you carefully steered her toward making an inventory order to boost your commissions and save your title? How inconvenient.

    Why do you have to do that? Does this make you proud of yourself when you ruin someone’s dreams? Hell yes. We gave her the information she needed to ask questions about the reality of the glowing dream you were luring her with.

    Why is it up to you to decide if people participate??? We don’t decide. We present facts. People who read the facts do the deciding.

    My team member was excited! She had already made her list of 100 people and we were going to meet to talk about her inventory options. Now she says she wants to “think about it” before ordering anything. Good. If it’s a sound investment, it can wait. Hustling for a decision is usually the sign of a con.

    She even asked me to show her how much I made last year. That is honestly none of her business. I don’t know why anyone thinks I need to show them a tax return, but I have to be nice about it or she might quit. You are telling her how successful you are, that she can have a real business, and yet you are incensed that she wants to know how successful your business is. Due diligence when investing in a business includes looking at the income and expenses of that business, the business debt load, the business banking accounts, the business credit card statements, the business tax returns. If you were an actual business you could hand over the BUSINESS records. But you are using personal accounts, aren’t you? And you have a boatload of credit card debt, don’t you?

    TWENTY years ago I spent a lot of time analyzing income from Mary Kay, using the data provided by sales directors in their newsletters. I updated it ELEVEN years ago. It was dismal then and it’s worse now.

    https://lazygardens.blogspot.com/2015/09/mary-kay-home-business-opportunity-or.html

    25
    • ARRGH forgot to close the HTML tag.
      She even asked me to show her how much I made last year. That is honestly none of her business. I don’t know why anyone thinks I need to show them a tax return, but I have to be nice about it or she might quit. You are telling her how successful you are, that she can have a real business, and yet you are incensed that she wants to know how successful your business is.
      Due diligence when investing in a business includes looking at the income and expenses of that business, the business debt load, the business banking accounts, the business credit card statements, the business tax returns. If you were an actual business you could hand over the BUSINESS records. But you are using personal accounts, aren’t you? And you have a boatload of credit card debt, don’t you?
      TWENTY years ago I spent a lot of time analyzing income from Mary Kay, using the data provided by sales directors in their newsletters. I updated it ELEVEN years ago. It was dismal then and it’s worse now.

      https://lazygardens.blogspot.com/2015/09/mary-kay-home-business-opportunity-or.html

      12
      • “If you were an actual business you could hand over the BUSINESS records. But you are using personal accounts, aren’t you?”

        Oh my dearie me. Putting your business into your personal account is a big no-no. The IRS don’t like this one little bit. It makes audits harder and it’s soooo easy to prepare a tax return from a commingled account isn’t it? It also doesn’t pass the IRS’s straight face test either. This was one of the things that got an MK hun into trouble with the IRS in tax court after an audit (that and using her daughter’s volleyball games and a trip to Disneyland Paris as business trip tax writeoffs – IRS said aw hell naw). She got interest, delinquencies and all the other fun prizes the IRS give out for tax fraud. MK Math tax folklore struck again:

        https://www.reddit.com/r/antiMLM/comments/1hswlyf/irs_audits_a_mk_consultant_and_it_goes_exactly/

        https://www.pinktruth.com/2025/01/02/truth-about-mary-kay-lies/#comment-331967

        Add to that none of the 9 requirements for profit motivation from Treasury Regulation §1.183-2(b) were met. She owed $10,000 at least to the IRS for that little escapade.

      • Yup. Now PTC’s credit card is going to have to do even more heavy lifting. It’s the end of the month so the scramble is on. Dial for dollars, manipulate, max out the credit cards. The rush is on. It’s make or break time. The unit could be lost if $4500 isn’t ordered by 23:59 tonight Dallas time.

  3. “My new team member was SO excited when she signed her agreement and then her sister sent her a link to this site.”

    YASSSSS!!! A caring and intelligent sister, and icing the kicker all in one. Beautiful.

    “Of course after reading here for an hour she suddenly had a million questions about inventory and how much directors make and how many people actually make money.”

    Of course? So you know that unless you hide the truth, people will ask perfectly sensible questions you have no answers to? Why do you think job ads always make a point of listing the salary and benefits?

    “…we were going to meet to talk about her inventory options.”

    Why does she need inventory, with My Shop sometimes almost working and the Agreement itself telling you not to carry more than you can reasonably sell? Oh, yeah, your commission. Admit it; you were going to strongarm her into buying the most expensive package and pick the stuff yourself so she’d have to constantly reorder.

    She wants to see your tax returns so you can prove that you actually make the money you say you do. Since you don’t, you’re trying to blame Pink Truth for your lies.

    “Successful people don’t spend hours researching all the reasons they might fail before they even get started.”

    LOLWUT. A bank won’t even give you a loan unless you do exactly that. My town won’t let you open a business unless you can answer questions about parking, occupancy, fire codes, road access, and pass all the inspections. If you can’t they won’t let you open no matter how much you pout.

    “And now our unit is short of our goal too, so thanks for that.”

    🎻

    21
  4. I really wish Pink Truth would stop ruining things for women who are excited about starting Mary Kay. My new team member was SO excited when she signed her agreement and then her sister sent her a link to this site.

    Good on her sister for having her back!

    Of course after reading here for an hour she suddenly had a million questions about inventory and how much directors make and how many people actually make money.

    I wonder why you, Ms. PTC were not open about all of this when you were talking to your latest recruit. Could it be that you personally didn’t want or need her to understand what a time and money pit the fauxpotunity you were pushing onto her?

    Why do you have to do that?

    We are simply offering up an alternative viewpoint.

    Does this make you proud of yourself when you ruin someone’s dreams?

    It’s not a good dream if looking at it from a more informed point of view causes it to crumble.

    Why is it up to you to decide if people partcipate(sic)???

    We are not doing that since we bee-lie-ve that these are adult women able to make their own decisions, even when we disagree with them.

    My team member was excited! She had already made her list of 100 people and we were going to meet to talk about her inventory options.

    Oh no! That’s over one hundred women who you didn’t get to bully offer the opportunity to!

    Now she says she wants to “think about it” before ordering anything.

    As she should!

    She even asked me to show her how much I made last year. That is honestly none of her business. I don’t know why anyone thinks I need to show them a tax return,

    Why not? Isn’t the oft touted siren call of “Executive Pay for Part-Time Work” correct? I wonder why you didn’t show her the Mary Kay Wagner Rogers Eckman Weaver Miller Hallenbeck Ash’s company’s income disclosure instead of your tax return.

    Oh right! They don’t publish one anywhere in the world apart from Canada where it is federal law. Here is a comparison of the 2024 and 2025 income disclosures.
    https://www.pinktruth.com/2026/03/02/pathetic-income-for-sales-directors-in-2025/

    but I have to be nice and about it or she might quit.

    And then you would lose not only her money and contacts but those of the people she know. And that’s your real concern, how many others you could exploit before they realise the Real Pink Truth.

    I told her there will always be negative people trying to steal your dream.

    Or worse, not allowing Ms. PTC to exploit her and her family, friends and exponentially other women in her orbit.

    If you go looking for reasons something won’t work, of course you’ll find them.

    Yes, it’s called ” due diligence”.

    Successful people don’t spend hours researching all the reasons they might fail before they even get started.

    Proof positive that you don’t understand how to actually run a “Real Business”. A business has people doing risk analysis on every major decision affecting the company. DO you think that Ryan just decided to rebrand white label products launch Korean inspired beauty products cold? Or did he have a team dedicated to researching the latest trends (LOL) to keep you competitive?

    She still hasn’t placed her inventory order and I’m pretty sure she’s not going to.

    Good for her for looking at the Risk Analysis and acting like a businesswoman.

    So congratulations Pink Truth. You probably think you saved her from something.

    All we did was offer a different perspective by showing what goes on behind the scenes, our stories and of course, the financial constraints of “owning a Mary Kay small business”.

    I think you just talked a woman out of taking a chance on herself.

    I think differently. I think she took a different chance, one that avoided being exploited by you and your up-line.

    And now our unit is short of our goal too, so thanks for that.

    Gosh! You sound “bitter”!

    18
    1
    • “And now our unit is short of our goal too, so thanks for that.”
      That’s my favorite part. This woman didn’t get to exploit someone else to meet a fake goal!

      23
      • This isn’t a problem apparently. 3-3-3, just do 30 faces that’s a cure for everything, go out and sell sell sell, trolling PT isn’t an IPA y’know. Raise your deserve level. Make a star level order. Stars drive cars. *insert generic trite aphorism that never worked even in 1963 here*

  5. If the Mary Kay opportunity truly empowered women, potential recruits would be encouraged to make a well educated decision. Instead, they are rushed and fed lies, half truths and statements omitting the actual reality of this pyramid scheme.

    17
  6. So, a prospect does her due diligence and asks legitimate basic risk-assessment questions and instead of answering honestly like a real business would, you get angry? That tells me all I need to know about you (scammer) and Mary Kay (scam).

    15
  7. “I really wish Pink Truth would stop ruining things for women who are excited about starting Mary Kay.” = Stop ruining things for ME!
    It wouldn’t worked except for you meddling kids!

    17
  8. Actually, your income IS her business, if you’re promising her that she can make money in Mary Kay. I suspect that if you were really making money yourself, you’d have told her just how much you’re making without even waiting for her to ask. It would be a huge selling point, after all.

    You’re not really sorry that someone ruined “her dream”. You’re just sore that you lost a commission.

    19
  9. At the risk of sounding like a total B, I have to say this is my favorite PTC post possibly ever. LOL!

    I wonder if Consumer Reports gets those same types of emails from car manufacturers?

    17
    • lol I can just imagine Ford going Greta Thurnberg “HOW DARE YOU!! Our diesel particulate filters don’t clog even when you drive 50 miles a day at 70mph and our PowerShift transmission IS reliable and doesn’t crap out for no reason at T-junctions nearly causing a multiple car pileup! IGNORE THE HATERZ AT CHANNEL 4 WHO LIE AND SAY OUR EXPLORER SUDDENLY ACCELERATES BY ITSELF AND KILLS MULTIPLE PEOPLE. Our tires DON’T BLOW OUT, that’s just a lie from Bridgestone. U-Haul are haterrzz (U-Haul didn’t rent to Explorer owners for liability reasons due to how unsafe the Explorer was). LIES! THE PINTO ISN’T A FIREBOMB ON WHEELS! COPS WEREN’T BLOWN UP IN REAR-END COLLISIONS IN THE CROWN VICTORIA BECAUSE THE GAS TANK IS MOUNTED UNDER THE TRUNK AND NOT BEHIND THE REAR AXLE! U R STEALING MOTORING DREAMS!” Well Ford did do that, but lied and concealed and conspired in a professional manner. Ford DID do a cost-benefit analysis and decided a $15 shield for the Pinto’s gas tank was too expensive. It was cheaper to pay out damages than prevent fiery explosions in the first place.

  10. I laughed out loud reading the first 2 paragraphs! Does she even realize she just told on herself?!

    Of course after reading here for an hour she suddenly had a million questions about inventory and how much directors make and how many people actually make money.

    Why do you have to do that? Does this make you proud of yourself when you ruin someone’s dreams? Why is it up to you to decide if people partcipate [sic]???

    So the mark is excited, then she suddenly has questions, and then the director jumps straight to “Why do you have to do that” and the ruination of dreams. Yes, these things do follow one after the other, just like that, which shows any impartial observer that today’s poster is a scammer. If someone asks questions and gets honest answers, then yes, she will decline, BECAUSE IT’S NOT IN HER BEST INTEREST. Why does PTC want the mark to do something that’s not in the mark’s best interest? Because PTC is a SCAMMER, and she will never admit it to herself or others. Sick and evil.

    “I don’t know why anyone thinks I need to show them a tax return.”

    I do. I know why. SCAMMER.

    19
  11. So you are upset because you got caught lying…you aren’t making that executive income among other things. LOL! Yeah sis watching out for her sis! This makes my evening!

  12. Indeed! Congratulations, Pink Truth!
    Unlike her sarcasm, I mean it. Congratulations for saving people from being exploited.

  13. This post is actually really funny. She’s mad because her new recruit wanted to know exactly what she was really getting into! And now our poster won’t receive a commission and a “ fancy fake ring” or some other trinket for getting an active team member with a big inventory order. She’s asking/telling pink truth to stop telling the truth about Mary Kay so consultants like her can keep exploiting and manipulating women into thinking they are starting a legitimate business. Completely laughable!

    • It’s worse than that. It’s not just the clearance Temu trinket. It’s the real possibility of losing the unit. Miss one month’s production you get a grace period. Next month you better meet production or unit goes bye-bye. So PTC’s credit cards are going to have to do heavy lifting. As are those of her downlines. It’s panic stations, it’s the end of the month. Right now she has 15 hours 8 minutes to find production for 23:59 Dallas time. MK did away with the orders on hold scam too so there’s a huge risk of the unit imploding because of us nasty Pink Truthers saving women from debt and heartbreak.

      • When I was in Mary Kay, I placed an order on the second or third day of the next month. Because I didn’t know about the grace period thing and that directors make up production with their own credit card every other month. I thought “does it really matter if she gets a commission from my order this month or next month? She’s supposedly making so much money after all”.
        My director called me when she saw my order and was like “ALWAYS order before month’s end, not the beginning of the next month, so we meet our unit goal.” But she couldn’t come right out and say why. It was such an awkward conversation. Hahaha. It’s a PITA to call your director on the last day of the month to have them order for you, though. Instead of just placing your order online.

        • And she didn’t tell you that an order placed late in the month is less useful to the IBC … its effect on your 50% discount goes by the calendar month, so 1 month of the 3-months was gone in a couple of days. Meaning you have to order sooner to keep the discount. And she profits from that, too.

  14. Ruined her dream? You mean prevented the NIGHTMARE.

    Honey-no one buys Mary Kay except Mary Kay consultants. I do not know one person that uses Mary Kay, This isn’t the 1980’s.

    Get real with yourself and get out of the pink fog.

    • My MUA girlfriend only knows about MK from PinkTruth. Our weekend hobby is going down the AntiMLM rabbit hole with takeout pizza and wine for her watching Sam Dee and Hannah Alanzo throw shade. Her kit (bridal makeup mostly) is an MLM-free zone. MLM isn’t a thing here at all, although I did walk past a house with an Arbonne sticker in the window a few years ago but it’s gone now. So they escaped the clutches of MLM. Or just ran out of money.

      As she has a real business she works in partnership with the bridal boutique. Unlike MK-David’s Bridal the customers know what and who they are signing up for and actually get a trained competent experienced MUA who can actually apply product to customers as she’s licensed, insured and registered as required by law. And free to advertise on Facebook and Instagram and where, when and how she sees fit. And doesn’t recruit her brides as her competition.

      But yes professional MUAs don’t use MLM products. They use things like Dior, MAC, Fenty, etc. I haven’t even seen MK in the wild, except when my mom bought some when MLMs spread like herpes through the mom-toddler group she was in. That was early 90s so pink case and the eyeshadows that had to be mixed with water to work. Using my GF as a baseline isn’t really great as she comes from old money. As I am a shareholder in a pharmacy chain I have access to market data. It’s about 75% drugstore, 20% mid-range including our own brand which is popular and the rest is high-ish end (Fenty being a consistent hot seller). In terms of supplements and vitamins they ebb and flow with an uptick happening about now as winter draws near and vitamin D goes like hotcakes. We have a loyalty card too. And this Christmas is debt free truly as I hoard points through the year.

      At the high price point of MK and poor product quality it’s hard to compete against Maybelline and Queen RhiRhi – who is always on trend. And they don’t constantly change the product line. Is this year’s MK foundation in ivory 3 the same as C110? Dunno. Have to have a 3 hour high pressure sales pitch to find out. And where did Fancy Nancy go? Oh yeah it’s now Fancy Coral as King Ryan fell out with Stepmommy Dearest. These things drive customers and consultants up the wall. But make oodles of dosh for MKC.

      But yes MLM products are generally unsellable. The only buyers are the poor “sales reps” who are stuck with it moldering in the garage and in basements. AntiMLM is mainstream now, MK is going affiliate so you don’t need inventory with MyShop which assigns orders to random people like the wheel of misfortune. And with the current trend being nude to invisible matte eyeshadow good luck with the shiny black shimmer sticks you have 100 of, and good luck with snail snot in the clean vegan beauty marketplace that has exploded.

      She’s been saved from an endless hamster wheel of frontload, order, recruit, stalk, harass, lose money, pile more inventory in the garage, overflow into the basement. and a trip to bankruptcy court.

      PTC is angry as there’s no Temu trinket and the unit may be in danger of being yoinked if production was missed in September. PTC has 6 hours until this month ends so those credit cards are working overtime and doing a lot of heavy lifting. The reason that the $3600 star inventory is touted is because unit production is $4500, so that gives breathing space for the director to prop up the unit.

      Her mark asked sensible questions anyone would ask that’s going into business. It’s due diligence. If MK was a golden opportunity what’s the problem with these questions? Is it because the answers aren’t great and honesty would send her running for the hills?

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts