Multi-level marketing companies will never tell you the truth about how many people lose money in their schemes. Some provide “income disclosure statements,” but those are massively deceptive. They omit important information such as the churn rate of distributors and the definition of an “active” distributor. Even more deceptive is they purposely omit data on tons of distributors who earn zero commissions, which makes the earnings numbers look better than they really are.
Two in-depth studies were done by academics who wanted to know the true failure rate of distributors involved in MLM. Robert FitzPatrick and Jon Taylor did separate studies using different methodologies, and both concluded that over 99% of of distributors lose money. The MLM companies try to explain this statistic away, saying most people don’t really want to make money anyway. But at the same time, the most common tool used to recruit people into multi-level marketing is the income claims. Recruiters defend their schemes by saying that there is an extremely high rate of failure across all small businesses. That’s not true. Depending on who you believe, probably 50% of small businesses fail within 2 to 4 years. But that’s a far cry from the 99% failure rate in MLM in the first year!
Below I discuss the details of the FitzPatrick’s findings. The two reports can be downloaded here:
- FitzPatrick Report: Myth of Income Opportunity in Multi-Level Marketing (conclusion on page 24)
- Taylor Report: MLM’s Abysmal Numbers (conclusion on page 25)
The FitzPatrick report included an analysis of 11 MLMs , including Arbonne, Cyberwize, Free Life, Herbalife, Melaleuca, Nikken, Nuskin, Reliv, Usana, Your Travel Business, and, Amway/Quixtar. Why only eleven companies? Because these were some of the few who distributed income disclosure statements. He focused on some larger ones, including five which were publicly traded companies. The annual revenue of these companies collectively exceeded $12 billion, and about 9 million people around the world were recruited into them each year.
The most important results of FitzPatrick’s work were the following:
- 99% of all distributors in these companies earned on average less than $13 a week in commission income. (In 10 of the 11 companies, the commissions were less than $10 a week.) This isn’t even enough money to cover the minimum purchases they’re required to make in order to “qualify” for commissions.
- Recruitment into these companies is largely based upon the offer of an “income opportunity,” yet these statistics show that the income opportunity is essentially non-existent and falsely promoted.
- Recruitment into these companies creates billions of dollars of losses to consumers each year.
- The losses of 99% of the distributors are transferred to less than 1% of the people at the top of the sales chain as “commissions.”
- The companies studied have essentially non-existent or unfeasible retail sales opportunities (i.e. participants can’t make much money selling the products because they’re overpriced).
- The promise of profit from retail sales by MLM sales representatives to consumers is the basis for the industry’s claim that it is a form of “direct selling,” yet virtually no multi-level marketing companies sell significant amounts of their products to the public and are therefore not in the “direct selling” business.
- The sales forces are churned (lost money/quit/replaced) at rates between 60-90% each year. Nearly all these churned sales people stop purchasing the products when they quit the schemes, indicating that they had made purchases primarily as part of the MLM income proposition in which they inevitably “failed.”
- The massive losses among MLM recruits are explained away by MLM’s lobbying organization with the claim that the great majority of MLM participants don’t want to earn money. They only are interested in buying the MLM goods at a “discount”, the Direct Selling Association claims. The explanation does not address the impossibility of broad-based profitability – regardless of time commitment, intention, motivation or levels of talent – in an “endless chain” recruitment model. The claim of “discount buyers” also does not account for the extraordinary churn rate among MLM participants, the majority of whom quit the schemes within a year and stop buying the MLM goods forever.
- The lack of broad-based and profitable retail selling is the single most telling sign that MLM companies are merely pyramid recruitment scams, not direct selling businesses. They have no “customers” and they have no profitable retail salespeople. A business in which almost none of its sales representatives earns a profit and almost none has a sustainable retail customer base cannot be called “direct selling.”
- In virtually all cases, MLMs require monthly or annual purchase quotas by the sales people in order to qualify for the promised “commissions and rebates” gained from new recruits. The required purchases gained by making false promises of future income account for virtually all of MLM “sales,” not consumer demand or legitimate marketing.
- Commission pay plans in these companies send most of the money to the very top levels:. One of the largest MLMs in the world sends 84% of all commissions to the top 1% of its distributor chain. What chance would the newest recruits at the bottom have to earn a profit?
- In half of the 10 companies, 70% or more of participants earned no income at all. For example, 96% of Arbonne’s sales representatives never earn any commissions at all. 80% of YTB’s “agents” also earned no commission at all. In other cases, the same pattern may exist, however, the companies hide that information by only counting the “active” participants or those “active for
What does all of this mean for Mary Kay? After all, won’t the Mary Kay supporters claim that Mary Kay is different from all of these companies and these aren’t their numbers?
They’re right… Mary Kay’s numbers aren’t included here because they don’t release them. Why don’t they release them? Because the numbers are so fabulous and support the claim that MK is a fabulous income opportunity? Or are these numbers hidden because they would be proof of the dismal opportunity Mary Kay really is? (I’ll guess the latter.)
Mary Kay may not be directly represented here, but you can bet their numbers are no better than these. We have former directors from all levels who can attest that these numbers are true for Mary Kay. Women are not making a living with Mary Kay. The very top distributors earn mostly small incomes (not real career earnings) and a very tiny number of distributors earn big money. Everyone else earns next to nothing… with most everyone else actually losing money.
Pingback: Reporter Declines to Think Critically About Mary Kay | Pink Truth
Pingback: Pink Truth » If You Spent As Much Time On Mary Kay As You Do On this Blog…
Pingback: Pink Truth » Mary Kay: A Real Job?
Pingback: Pink Truth » Harper’s Magazine: Mary Kay’s Pink Pyramid Scheme
Pingback: Pink Truth » Common Misrepresentations by Recruiting MLMs
Pingback: Another Jab For the Lazy Losers Who Failed at Mary Kay | Pink Truth
Pingback: The Truth About Mary Kay, Stella & Dot, Scentsy, and Other Female-Oriented 'Home Business' Schemes
Pingback: The Mary Kay “Sales Tactics” Are Evil | Pink Truth
Pingback: Fraud Files Blog Internet Marketing and Multi-Level Marketing: Same Scam, Different Name » Fraud Files Blog
Pingback: Fraud Files Blog More on Herbalife, Bill Ackman, and Law Enforcement » Fraud Files Blog
Pingback: Pink Truth » Welcome, New Visitors to Pink Truth
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Fortune Hi Tech Marketing Pyramid Scheme Shut Down
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Create Your Own MLM in Ten Easy Steps
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Is Multi-Level Marketing a Legitimate Business Method?
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Xyngular: Starve, Binge, Purge, Repeat!
Pingback: Pink Truth » Help Me Recruit You into Mary Kay
Pingback: Pink Truth » Women Don’t Join Mary Kay to “Have Fun”
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » How Does Multi-Level Marketing Affect People?
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Jennifer McKinney Can Pay Her Creditors
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Dave Ramsey Officially Sucks
Pingback: Pink Truth » Dave Ramsey Sucks
Pingback: RANT | Financial Guru Dave Ramsey Promotes Multi-Level Marketing Scams | Peschel Report
Pingback: Pink Truth » The Market For Mary Kay Products
Pingback: The ‘Sharks’ of Mary Kay Cosmetics
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » Losing Money in Herbalife
Pingback: The Truth About Mary Kay, Stella & Dot, Scentsy, and Other Female-Oriented ‘Home Business’ Schemes | Stephanie Peterson
Pingback: Pink Truth » My Favorite Mary Kay Lies
Pingback: Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog » World Ventures Called A Scam by Blogger and Others
Pingback: Pink Truth » Gloria Mayfield Banks at Seminar
Pingback: Multi-level marketing: the misapplication of social capital | Wait, what?!
Pingback: Why Products Offered by Multi-Level Marketing Companies Are So Expensive | Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Pink Truth » Mary Kay Says They’re Not a Pyramid
Pingback: Pink Truth » Mary Kay’s Pink Pyramid Scheme (from Harper’s Magazine)
Pingback: Pink Truth » Mary Kay Top Director Income
Pingback: Pink Truth » Linda Toupin’s Mary Kay Husband Letter
Pingback: Multi-Level Marketing is not a Business (It’s a Pyramid Scheme) | Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Beware Vague Opportunities
Pingback: Pink Truth » Mary Kay’s Pink Pyramid Scheme
Pingback: Pink Truth » Another Jab For the Lazy Losers Who Failed at Mary Kay
Pingback: Pink Truth » Pink Truth Is a “Public Display of Your Fundamental Personality Flaws”
Pingback: Read This Before You Start Your "WAHM" Job • NerdyGirl
Pingback: Mommy Blogger Academy | The Good, The Bad and The Ugly: WAHM Job Opportunities
Pingback: Herbalife: os líderes mentem, os números não (III) « Ganhar Dinheiro Extra
Pingback: MAMA VIA SPEAKS-MULTI-LEVEL MARKETING | Anything you say May be Used Against You
Pingback: Pink Truth » The Mary Kay “Sales Tactics” Are Evil
Pingback: Pink Truth » Help Me Recruit You into Mary Kay
Pingback: Mary Kay is NOT a Business Opportunity | Pink Truth
Pingback: Pink Truth and Mary Kay on ABC’s 20/20 | Pink Truth
Pingback: Pink Truth and Mary Kay on ABC’s 20/20 | Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Mary Kay on the 20/20 “Not So Pretty In Pink” Story | Pink Truth
Pingback: Women Don’t Join Mary Kay to “Have Fun” | Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay is Not a Business | Pink Truth
Pingback: No błagam, tylko nie MLM! | bumelancik.pl
Pingback: Herbalife Victims Video: Almost Everyone Loses Money in MLM | Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Multi-Level Marketing Victims Speak | Pink Truth
Pingback: ESPN on AdvoCare | Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: ESPN the Magazine on Advocare – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Directors: People Will Disappoint You But Numbers Never Lie – Pink Truth
Pingback: MLM: It’s About Recruiting, Not Sales | Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Your Stupid Pyramid Scheme Sucks - The Frugal Vagabond
Pingback: Millenials Suckered as Avon Rejuvenates – Pink Truth
Pingback: My Favorite Mary Kay Lies – Pink Truth
Pingback: John Oliver Exposes the Scam of Multi-Level Marketing – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: More on John Oliver’s Takedown of Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: LuLaRoe Review: Bad “Business” – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Comparing MLM and Corporate America – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Why MLM is NOT a Business - Lazy Man and Money
Pingback: False Earnings Claims in Mary Kay Cosmetics – Pink Truth
Pingback: Loss and Failure Rates in Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: LuLaRoe Scam Review: A Bad “Business” for Women – Pink Truth
Pingback: Multi-Level Marketing in Uganda – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: LuLaRoe Fraud Complaints – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: My Toddler Learned About MLM from this 2500 Year Old Fable - Lazy Man and Money
Pingback: Pink Truth is a “Waste of Time and Resources” – Pink Truth
Pingback: Real Numbers From a LuLaRoe Consultant – Pink Truth
Pingback: No Such Things as a Good MLM – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Mary Kay Lies: Unlimited Earning Potential – Pink Truth
Pingback: Stop Comparing Your MLM Sales My Small Business – Okayest Moms
Pingback: Why MLM Distributors Can’t Make Money Selling Products – Pink Truth
Pingback: MLM Recruiting Lies – Pink Truth
Pingback: Almost Everyone Loses Money in MLM – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Kuidas Facebook 1 euroga võrkturunduses külmi müügikohtumis teha?
Pingback: The Shocking Truth about Pyramid MLM Scams | The Indie Mag
Pingback: Almost No One Makes Money in MLM – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: My Objections to Multi-Level Marketing - Jenn Wells Design Blog | Jenn Wells Design Blog
Pingback: Mary Kay Sales Directors Earn $5k to $25k Per Month (No They Don’t!) – Pink Truth
Pingback: A LuLaRoe Consultant Responds – Pink Truth
Pingback: LuLaRoe Business Review: Still a Scam – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay New Year, New You – Pink Truth
Pingback: Women Don’t Join Mary Kay to “Have Fun” – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay is Not a Business – Pink Truth
Pingback: MARKETING MULTINIVEL te deixa POBRE – Whatsapp Blog
Pingback: Mary Kay’s Air of Suspicion – Pink Truth
Pingback: Multi-Level Marketing Victims Speak – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Review: Enriching Women's Lives or Empty Pink Lies?
Pingback: Mary Kay Review: Enriching Women's Lives or Empty Pink Lies? | Best MLM, Network Marketing & Franchise Companies
Pingback: It Works! Review: Crazy Wrap Things
Pingback: Do Not Demotivate Mary Kay Ladies – Pink Truth
Pingback: So You Can't Work From Home Stuffing Envelopes. What Can You Do?
Pingback: The Mary Kay Guilt Trip – Pink Truth
Pingback: 5 Ways New Distributors Are Being Set Up To Fail – Bart Rippl
Pingback: A Requiem For “Old School” MLM – Bart Rippl
Pingback: MLM Vs Job : Don't be a Sheep !
Pingback: Common Misrepresentations in MLM Recruiting – Pink Truth
Pingback: Multi-Level Marketing is Not Like Corporate America – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Almost Everyone Loses Money in MLM – Fraud Files Forensic Accounting Blog
Pingback: Deceptions Used to Recruit Women into Mary Kay – Pink Truth
Pingback: Pink Truth is a Waste of Time – Pink Truth
Pingback: If You Spent as Much Time on Mary Kay…. – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Top Director Income – Pink Truth
Pingback: False Earnings Claims (Again) – Pink Truth
Pingback: A Letter Template for a Friend Who Added You to their MLM Group - The Anti-MLM Coalition
Pingback: Elle & Bot speak on Sounds Like MLM But OK podcast - The Anti-MLM Coalition
Pingback: What About Amway? - The Anti-MLM Coalition
Pingback: Is Mary Kay a Real Job? – Pink Truth
Pingback: Why MLM is Bad and Why You Should Avoid It | Make Money Online
Pingback: Social Media Influencer Natalia Taylor Exposes Mary Kay Scam – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Facial Scam – Pink Truth
Pingback: Exploiting the Panic – Pink Truth
Pingback: Recruiting Lies in Mary Kay – Pink Truth
Pingback: Why MLM Distributors Can’t Make Money Retailing Products – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Emotional Manipulation – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Isn’t For Everyone – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay is Not a Business Opportunity – Pink Truth
Pingback: Let’s Talk About Chelsea’s Lies – Pink Truth
Pingback: Symptoms That a Director Does Not Have a Strong Personal Business – Pink Truth
Pingback: “Creating Jobs” in Mary Kay – Pink Truth
Pingback: The Mary Kay Numbers Game – Pink Truth
Pingback: Don’t Join Mary Kay to Have Fun – Pink Truth
Pingback: Stifling Enthusiasm in New Mary Kay Consultants – Pink Truth
Pingback: Getting Rich at the Expense of Other Women – Pink Truth
Pingback: Why MLM is NOT a Business - Lazy Man and Money
Pingback: Know How to Identify a Scam Job Post - BendOregonJobs.com
Pingback: Wasting Time on Pink Truth – Pink Truth
Pingback: The Market for Mary Kay – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Numbers Don’t Lie – Pink Truth
Pingback: Mary Kay Magic Words – Pink Truth