Show Both Sides
I just recently came across this site because I was trying to learn more about Mary Kay and see what people were saying about it. After reading for a while, I have to say something feels off. Almost every story here is negative, and it makes the whole site come across more like a complaint board than anything else.
If you really want people to take Pink Truth seriously, you should probably show both sides of the story. Right now it just sounds like a group of people venting about their bad experiences. I’m sure that’s therapeutic for some of you, but it doesn’t exactly build credibility.
Organizations like the Better Business Bureau at least try to look at both perspectives before making conclusions. That’s why people trust them. Here, it just feels like everything automatically gets blamed on Mary Kay no matter what the situation was.
For example, what about the cases where someone makes poor financial decisions on their own and then turns around and blames the company? That happens too. Not every bad outcome is proof that the business itself is flawed.
Honestly, reading all these posts hasn’t scared me away from Mary Kay at all. If anything it makes me question the reliability of the stories being told here. It would probably help your case a lot if you verified things and showed a little more balance instead of assuming the company is always the villain.
Visit the
The 7,643,566,543,887,654,678 MK-sanctioned websites, Facebook pages, and Instagram posts singing the praises of MK with no negativity allowed are thataway ↕️↔️🔄
Tracy owns the site, so she gets to choose the content. There’s no “case” to “prove” because this is a forum for sharing opinions and experiences, not a court of law (or binding arbitration, if you signed the new consultant agreement and forgot to opt out).
And Ms. PTC has the whole of the World Wide Web to create her own website to tell “Her Truth” about ” Mary Kay Wagner Rogers Eckman Weaver Miller Hallenbeck Ash’s company”. And Ms. PTC’s minor role in making Ryan Rogers a lil bit more monies.
PTC, if MK recruiters were held to this standard, there would be no need for Pink Truth. Should MK recruiters be required to tell both sides of the story? Should they be required to tell recruits that nearly all of them will fail financially no matter how hard they work? Should they be required to be honest about how difficult it is to sell overpriced retail products out of your home? Or just how many people must lose money in your own downline so you can turn a profit?
Pink Truth exists precisely because MK recruiters are not held to your standard of telling both sides of the story. Maybe focus your energy on cleaning up the MK side before asking Pink Truth to change. If you succeed, PT will no longer be necessary.
“MK recruiters were held to this standard, there would be no need for Pink Truth”
This statement says it all.
Thank Data Junkie.
The BBB isn’t the saintly organization most people are led to believe. There are a great number of businesses that no longer partner with the BBB.
Also, I have yet to see anyone refute what has been shared here. This site has many former directors and consultants who were “successful” by MK’s own standards. We show the side of MK that gets buried by the 7,643,566,543,887,654,678 MK-sanctioned websites, Facebook pages, and Instagram posts (Popinki, 2026).
I’m a footnote! I’ve arrived, baby! 🤩
FFS, “Organizations like the Better Business Bureau at least try to look at both perspectives before making conclusions.” It’s pay to play. Not a member but got a BBB complaint? Just become a member and voila! “Resolved.”
We did make a correction about an IBC’s husband being a board certified plastic surgeon when the PT article said he wasn’t.
I remember it because I found the facts and Tracy made the edits. As it turned out, the certification board was slow to update its records and when the article was published he was NOT listed.
So we WILL fix things if the facts are there.
That’s responsible journalism, to correct the facts as and when new or updated information is found.
I just recently came across this site because I was trying to learn more about Mary Kay and see what people were saying about it.
I wonder why you were looking.
After reading for a while, I have to say something feels off. Almost every story here is negative, and it makes the whole site come across more like a complaint board than anything else.
I think you need to re-read and see who are complaining. Clue, it’s not us.
If you really want people to take Pink Truth seriously, you should probably show both sides of the story.
Why? Do you rebuke anti-Wal*Mart sites in the same way? Do you demand Disney Cast Members show both sides of working long hours in hot sweaty costumes?
Right now it just sounds like a group of people venting about their bad experiences. I’m sure that’s therapeutic for some of you, but it doesn’t exactly build credibility.
Except it’s not. Look again. Read some more posts. Look at who is writing what in the directors groups. Whose bad experience is it when My Shop directs some-one’s long term customer to another consultant?
Organizations like the Better Business Bureau at least try to look at both perspectives before making conclusions. That’s why people trust them.
BBB is a “pay for play” organisation. That’s why I don’t trust them.
Here, it just feels like everything automatically gets blamed on Mary Kay no matter what the situation was.
No, women have taken responsibility for their own actions.
For example, what about the cases where someone makes poor financial decisions on their own and then turns around and blames the company?
That could be valid except that directors like Cleta are making training videos explaining how to make a new consultomer buy a $3,600 “starter” kit. Those “poor financial decisions” are enriching those higher up the pyramid.
That happens too. Not every bad outcome is proof that the business itself is flawed.
Per FTC, for one person to make any kind of profit in an MLM, 249 other people must make a loss. Sound likes a flawed business model to me.
Honestly, reading all these posts hasn’t scared me away from Mary Kay at all.
That’s a shame but when you realise that you were promised a dream but sold a nightmare, we will still be here to help and support you.
If anything it makes me question the reliability of the stories being told here.
There are far fewer “I Stories” told here than there are screen shots from directors groups complaining about something or other with the same old, useless advice being proffered as something novel or different.
It would probably help your case a lot if you verified things and showed a little more balance instead of assuming the company is always the villain.
Try reading some of the names on the screen shots, those complaining are not us. They are the sales directors who call other women “heffers” or bitch about strangers not wanting to be bothered at brunch.
You might find this interesting. It’s Mary Kay Canada’s own figures, so it’s a verified source. It’s a comparison of 2024 vs 2025 commissions.
https://www.pinktruth.com/2026/03/02/pathetic-income-for-sales-directors-in-2025/
This IS the other side of the story.
Mary Kay, Inc, has its own website, where it promotes all the alleged positives of becoming a consultant. Why aren’t you insisting that they tell the negatives as well?
The same goes for all the pro-MK social media groups. Are you also scolding them for not telling both sides?
Please stop and use your critical thinking skills for a moment. Why do you believe that every MK-related website must include a positive spin on MK, while none of them is obligated to include truthful negative information? What false assumptions are you working from?
I’ll take $400 for who is a consultant Alex.
Delusion and reading WITHOUT comprehension is strong with this one. Go prove us wrong! Sign up immediately and tell us how much money you are really making. I dare you prove us wrong. Be sure to open a credit card and have your director place the biggest possible order for you. Show us how it flys off your shelves. I double dog dare you! We are waiting!