How Mary Kay Turns Your Friends and Family Into Targets

When a woman first signs up for Mary Kay, one of the first things she’s told to do is practice her facials and skin care classes on friends and family. It sounds perfectly reasonable. Most new consultants have little or no sales experience, don’t know much about skin care, and aren’t exactly comfortable standing in front of a room full of strangers trying to sell makeup.

Her recruiter reassures her that she doesn’t need to know everything right away. Just “fake it till you make it,” be enthusiastic, and remember that friends and family won’t care if she makes a few mistakes. They’re the perfect people to practice on because they already know and trust her. In Mary Kay, this group is called her “warm market.”

What a thoughtful way to help a nervous new consultant get started! Except there’s a little more going on here than helping her learn how to demonstrate moisturizer.

The recruiter wants her new consultant to experience some quick success. Nothing builds excitement like making a few sales right after signing up. And who is most likely to buy something from a woman who just started selling makeup? Her mother, sister, best friend, aunt, and coworkers. These women may not need another lipstick or cleanser, but they’ll often buy something because they want to be supportive.

Some call these “pressure purchases” or “pity purchases.” They’re a big part of how new Mary Kay consultants get started, and most consultants don’t even realize it.

The problem is that selling products to people who love you doesn’t prove you have a viable business. Your mother might spend $100 because she’s proud of you. Your best friend might host a party because she doesn’t want to disappoint you. Your coworkers might buy a few things to be nice. None of that tells you whether strangers will want your products or whether you can consistently find enough paying customers to make a profit.

But Mary Kay treats those first sales as proof that the opportunity works. Look how easy it was! The products practically sell themselves! Just imagine what you could accomplish if you really worked your business!

And wouldn’t this be a great time to place a nice big inventory order?

Eventually, the new consultant runs through her warm market. Her friends have already purchased what they’re willing to buy, and her family members have stopped answering every invitation to another skin care class. Now she needs to find customers who don’t know her, don’t feel obligated to help her, and probably already have favorite skin care and makeup products.

That’s when things get way harder and reality sets in. Every consultant runs up against the same problem… where to find new blood.

Most women don’t enjoy approaching strangers at the grocery store, striking up fake conversations, and trying to turn them into customers. They don’t like asking acquaintances for the names and phone numbers of their friends. And they certainly don’t enjoy hearing “no” over and over again. But these are the things a consultant eventually has to do if she wants to keep finding new customers.

Meanwhile, her recruiter has another idea. Why not bring Mom or your sister to the next unit meeting? Wouldn’t your best friend enjoy being pampered at a special event? Maybe that coworker who bought a skincare set would love to hear about the opportunity. After all, it would be selfish not to share something so wonderful with the people you care about!

Things get worse from here. Instead of just selling products to friends and family, now we’re recruiting them. You bring your sister to a unit meeting or nsd event, and suddenly she’s hearing about executive income, free cars, flexible schedules, and all the wonderful things Mary Kay can supposedly provide. She might hear stories about women replacing their full-time salaries or staying home with their children while earning money on their own terms.

What she probably won’t hear is how difficult it is to find customers, how much unsold inventory consultants have sitting in their homes, or how many women spend more on their Mary Kay businesses than they ever earn. She won’t hear much about the constant pressure to order products, recruit new consultants, and meet production goals.

Mary Kay recruiters have long used the excuse that giving prospects too much information will overwhelm them. Apparently, it’s better to let a woman sign an agreement and discover the unpleasant details later. By then, she may have already purchased hundreds or thousands of dollars in inventory.

And remember, the recruiter has a financial interest in getting these women to sign up and order products. The director has an even bigger interest because those orders count toward her unit production, commissions, and qualifications for recognition. The new consultant thinks she’s sharing a wonderful opportunity with people she loves. The women above her see potential recruits and wholesale orders.

Eventually, some of those friends and family members may discover that the opportunity wasn’t quite what they were promised. They may resent being pressured to buy products, attend meetings, or join a business they never really wanted. And the original consultant may find herself trying to explain why she encouraged people she loves to get involved in something she now regrets joining herself.

Mary Kay loves to talk about enriching women’s lives and building relationships. Yet the recruiting system encourages consultants to view nearly every woman they know as a potential customer or recruit. Friendships become sales opportunities, family gatherings become chances to book appointments, and ordinary conversations turn into attempts to get someone interested in the business.

Your friends and family trusted you long before Mary Kay entered the picture. They shouldn’t have to wonder whether you’re calling because you want to spend time with them or because your director needs another $600 wholesale order before the end of the month.

Those relationships are worth a whole lot more than anything Mary Kay is offering.

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts