Free Hit Counter Pink Truth - Mary Kay Not Taught at Harvard

http://www.pinktruth.com

Mary Kay Not Taught at Harvard PDF Print E-mail
Time and again, the Kaybots (and other scammy MLM participants) brag that their “marketing plan is taught at Harvard”. Well, it’s not. ImageMany Mary Kay distributors are convinced that the "Mary Kay marketing plan" is taught at Harvard. It's not, and even if it was, that wouldn't mean Mary Kay is necessarily a good or legitimate marketing plan.

The Truth: Harvard Business School has published case studies on a variety of businesses, including Mary Kay, but that does NOT mean that MK is “taught” or “studied” at Harvard. The particular business plan in question focused on the prizes offered by Mary Kay, and how effective they are at encouraging consultants and directors to buy more. 

One of our members went right to the source and asked Harvard about exactly what is and is not taught there. And the response was clear:Harvard Business School does NOT teach multi-level marketing and does not endorse it in any way.

An article about this topic was even done by the Wall Street Journal in 1995. Here are some excerpts from the article:

Of particular concern these days is the increasing number of claims that the business school endorses multilevel marketing, in which distributors earn commissions on products that they or their recruits sell. “If the registrar’s office had a dollar for every call we’ve had over the years over whether Harvard Business School teaches multilevel marketing or has studies on it, we could throw a very nice Christmas party,” reads one internal business-school memo. “This claim is harder to kill than a dandelion.

“What was once a nuisance now looks like grounds for potential defamation or libel lawsuits, says Frank J. Connors, a Harvard lawyer. Some handouts, for example, now claim — falsely — that Harvard has conducted “extensive research in the network marketing industry,” and that the business school calls multilevel marketing “a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.”

Many of the current myths about Harvard and multilevel marketing stem from a 1984 article widely used to recruit distributors, multilevel experts say. The article, by multilevel consultant Beverly Nadler, states without attribution that Harvard teaches multilevel marketing.

Harvard Business School marketing Prof. Robert J. Dolan worries that people may join multilevel marketing companies because they mistakenly believe Harvard condones the practice. “You hate to see your name used in a way that you haven’t approved,” he says. “Then you think of all the people who are being led down a path to some financial distress.”

 

So let's quit perpetuating the Harvard lie, shall we? 

Comments
Search
samisone  - Harvard   |2010-01-28 01:43:33
Hello,
I am a second year MBA student at a highly-ranked public institution (not Harvard). Harvard is obviously a stronger brand than Mary Kay if Mary Kay is trying to use the Harvard brand to boost its own brand.

During the past year and a half of business school, I have probably read over 100 Harvard Business Cases. Read one today. The idea of a Mary Kay case study is pretty ridiculous. Cases are teaching tools. They give students a background on the company and then information regarding a serious issue the company faced. No solution to the issue is provided because discussing and researching the solution is how students' learn from cases. See this link for information from Harvard on how cases should be used: http://www.hbs.edu/mba/academi cs/howthecasemethodworks.html

In order for there to be a Mary Kay case study, Mary Kay would have to allowed Harvard to publish an article about a major issue the company faced without providing the company's solution to the issue (that is for the students to figure out and learn from). Students can't learn from half truths and Mary Kay probably wouldn't provide enough info to document a passable case study.

If you want to see what a REAL Harvard case looks like, you can download one for $6.95. Here is a link to purchase one I have studied for a class. http://hbr.org/product/henry-t am-and-the-mgi-team/an/404068- PDF-ENG?referral=00161

Happy reading!
Only registered users can write comments!

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 
< Prev

Private Messages

You are not logged in.

Contact Pink Truth

Send your news and comments to This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .

For questions about Mary Kay, recruiting, products, or returning inventory, please register for an account and post your questions and comments on our discussion board.

Pink Truth RSS Feed

Subscribe here

Login

Recent Comments

CB Workflows

Pink Lie

Pink Lie - noun - In contrast with a white lie, which intends very little harm, a Pink Lie is self serving and intended to hide the truth not by overt manifestation but by omission. A  Pink Lie is true only to the extent that it gives partial information and depends on assumptions and omissions in order to blame shift any destructive results. (ie: nobody held a gun to your head)

Product Returns

Total inventory returned to Mary Kay by Pink Truth members:

$3,686,431 retail

Add your return to our total here.